India has made considerable progress in reducing poverty over the past decade, but determining how many people remain economically vulnerable continues to be a challenge. Different research institutions and methodologies produce significantly different estimates, with the proportion of people classified as poor ranging from around 5% to more than 26%.
The debate is not simply about calculating a percentage. It concerns the benchmark used to define poverty, the cost of meeting basic needs and whether existing measurements adequately reflect the economic realities faced by households.
A recent analysis highlights how the same country, during the same period, can produce sharply different poverty estimates depending on the poverty threshold selected.
Why Does the Poverty Line Make Such a Difference?
The World Bank's international poverty estimates provide a clear example of how changing the benchmark affects the results.
For India in 2022–23, the estimated poverty rate was approximately:
2.6% using the international poverty line of $3 per person per day, adjusted for 2021 purchasing power parity (PPP).
16.1% using the $4.20 benchmark applicable to lower-middle-income countries.
Both estimates examine the same country and year. The difference arises primarily because the second benchmark sets a higher threshold for determining who is considered poor.
This distinction is important because a low extreme-poverty rate does not necessarily mean that economic hardship has disappeared. People living above an extremely low poverty threshold may still struggle to afford essential goods and services.
The selected poverty line therefore influences how policymakers and researchers understand the scale of economic vulnerability.
Different Indian Estimates Produce Different Results
India's domestic poverty estimates also vary considerably because researchers use different approaches to calculate the minimum consumption expenditure required to avoid poverty.
Several studies illustrate this difference:
Research estimate | Poverty rate or threshold |
|---|---|
SBI Research (2025), inflation-adjusted Tendulkar method | Rural: 7.2%; Urban: 4.6% |
Rangarajan and Dev (2014), inflation-adjusted Rangarajan method | 10.8% |
Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024), reconstructed Rangarajan method | 26.4% |
The estimates use different poverty thresholds and methodological assumptions, so they should not be treated as directly interchangeable.
The differences become clearer when comparing the monthly per-person consumption thresholds.
How Monthly Poverty Thresholds Change the Results
SBI Research's inflation-adjusted Tendulkar-based estimates use monthly consumption thresholds of approximately ₹1,632 per person in rural areas and ₹1,944 in urban areas for 2022–23.
By comparison, the approach used by Sethu, Surya and Ruthu applies higher thresholds:
Area | SBI Research threshold | Sethu et al. threshold |
|---|---|---|
Rural | ₹1,632 per month | ₹2,515 per month |
Urban | ₹1,944 per month | ₹3,639 per month |
When the minimum expenditure considered necessary to avoid poverty increases, more households fall below the poverty line. This explains a substantial part of the difference between the estimates.
However, the methodology also matters. One approach updates an older poverty line using inflation, while another reconstructs the benchmark using consumption patterns recorded in a newer household survey.
Each method answers a somewhat different question and has its own limitations.
Why Reliable Poverty Measurement Matters
Poverty estimates are important beyond academic research. Governments and policymakers use them to understand economic conditions, assess development progress and evaluate the reach of welfare programmes.
When estimates vary significantly, it becomes harder to determine how much progress has been achieved and which sections of the population continue to face economic insecurity.
A credible benchmark can help policymakers:
Assess changes in poverty over time.
Identify households that remain economically vulnerable.
Evaluate whether welfare programmes are reaching their intended beneficiaries.
Compare rural and urban living conditions.
Design policies around realistic household consumption requirements.
Beyond Income: The Importance of Multidimensional Poverty
Consumption-based poverty measurements provide important information, but they cannot capture every aspect of deprivation.
Multidimensional poverty has therefore gained greater attention in economic research and policy discussions. This approach considers several aspects of living conditions rather than relying only on household expenditure.
It recognises that economic well-being can also be affected by access to essential services and other basic requirements.
A broader measurement framework can therefore provide additional context when evaluating poverty and living standards. However, different measures should be clearly distinguished rather than combined into a single figure without explaining their underlying assumptions.
The Need for a Credible and Consistent Benchmark
India's progress in poverty reduction is an important part of its economic development story. However, understanding the remaining challenges requires measurements that are transparent, consistent and relevant to changing consumption patterns.
The wide variation between existing estimates demonstrates why the choice of poverty line matters. A lower benchmark may capture extreme deprivation, while a higher threshold can reveal a wider population facing financial insecurity.
Ultimately, reliable poverty measurement is necessary to assess both the progress already achieved and the challenges that remain. Without a credible and consistently applied benchmark, it becomes difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of development policies or determine how much further progress is required.