A Telangana consumer commission has directed a bank to compensate a Hyderabad-based software engineer after ₹4.06 lakh was lost in an alleged online banking fraud linked to a flight ticket cancellation attempt. The ruling highlights the responsibility of banks to examine unauthorised electronic transactions carefully and establish customer negligence through credible evidence before holding account holders liable.
The Ranga Reddy District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission partly allowed a complaint filed by software engineer K. Chandra Shekar Prasad. In its October 28 order, the commission directed the bank and its officials to refund the disputed amount with interest and pay additional litigation costs.
How Did the Flight Cancellation Fraud Begin?
The dispute originated on July 4, 2023, when Prasad and his sister reportedly searched online for customer-care contact details to cancel a flight ticket and obtain a refund.
According to the complaint, the siblings subsequently came into contact with individuals allegedly posing as customer-support representatives. The interaction reportedly resulted in unauthorised access to their banking facilities and financial losses.
The bank argued that the complainants had installed a remote-access Android application while attempting to resolve the flight cancellation issue. According to the bank, this application enabled outsiders to access their mobile devices.
Prasad, however, disputed the suggestion that he had knowingly disclosed confidential banking credentials or authorised the transactions.
How Were ₹4.53 Lakh in Transactions Carried Out?
According to the commission's order, the disputed transactions involving Prasad's accounts included:
₹98,503: Transferred from his savings account.
₹3.08 lakh: Withdrawn through a salary overdraft account that he allegedly claimed was opened without his knowledge or informed consent.
₹47,000: Separately lost by his sister.
The combined losses of the siblings amounted to approximately ₹4.53 lakh. However, the consumer complaint considered by the commission concerned Prasad's individual loss of ₹4.06 lakh.
Prasad stated that the disputed transactions took place between 3:45 pm and 4:15 pm. He further claimed that he contacted the bank within approximately 30 minutes of noticing the transactions.
Although the bank acknowledged his complaint at 5:38 pm, he alleged that the beneficiary banks were informed only around 7:32 pm and 7:36 pm. The timing of these communications became relevant to the dispute over how the bank handled the fraud report.
Why Did the Consumer Commission Reject the Bank's Defence?
The bank maintained that the disputed transactions had been authenticated through its mobile banking application using security credentials, including one-time passwords (OTPs) and PINs. It also argued that debit-card grid authentication was required for the overdraft facility.
However, the Ranga Reddy District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission found that the bank had not produced sufficient evidence to establish that Prasad had knowingly shared his confidential banking information with fraudsters.
The commission also took note of the bank's own investigation report, which reportedly described its findings as inconclusive.
It observed that allegations of customer negligence could not be established merely through assumptions about the possible disclosure of banking credentials. The bank was expected to provide reliable supporting evidence before attributing responsibility to the complainant.
This distinction is significant in electronic banking disputes, where the use of an OTP or PIN does not, by itself, necessarily establish that the account holder knowingly authorised a disputed transaction.
What Compensation Did the Commission Award?
The commission, comprising President Chitneni Latha Kumari and members D. Madhavi Latha and Kathyayani Khandavilli, partly allowed Prasad's complaint through its October 28 order.
It directed the bank and its officials, jointly and severally, to provide:
₹4.06 lakh as a refund of the disputed amount.
6% annual interest on the refund amount from May 6, 2024, until payment.
₹10,000 towards litigation expenses.
The refund and litigation costs together amount to approximately ₹4.16 lakh, excluding the applicable interest.
The commission relied on the Reserve Bank of India's July 6, 2017 circular concerning customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions. It also rejected the bank's argument that pending criminal proceedings prevented the consumer commission from examining the complaint.
The commission held that a customer could independently pursue consumer relief in cases involving an alleged deficiency in banking services.
What Does the Ruling Mean for Banking Customers?
The decision highlights the importance of timely fraud reporting, proper investigation and transparent banking procedures. It also underlines that banks must assess disputed transactions on the basis of available evidence rather than automatically attributing losses to customers.
Consumers should remain cautious when searching online for airline, railway or other customer-care numbers. Fraudsters may exploit search results and impersonate legitimate support representatives to obtain access to personal or financial information.
Anyone facing suspicious banking activity should contact their bank through its verified official channels and report suspected cyber fraud promptly. Maintaining transaction records and complaint acknowledgements can also help when seeking a resolution.
For businesses and individuals reviewing suspicious financial transactions, financial investigation services can support the examination of financial irregularities and transaction-related concerns.
The ruling serves as a reminder that digital banking security involves responsibilities on both sides: customers must protect their credentials, while financial institutions must investigate unauthorised transactions fairly and support their conclusions with credible evidence.